Changing the cottage

The tricky calculus of “home improvement”
Rate this item
(0 votes)

In April, my wife and I made the 600-​mile drive to Michigan’s Upper Peninsula unusually early. We went to meet with contractors to begin fixing up the old cottage.


What we call “The Big Cottage” was completed for the summer of 1908, the first built on LaSalle Island along the northern shore of Lake Huron. You can reach it only by boat, which dampens its real estate value but increases its charm, though my wife debates the latter. It has seen six generations of my family, and the old wooden dining room wall shows the height of all of us, measured from our first summer to maturity. The old house has witnessed the happiest of times and the most tragic as well.

The cottage somehow is both surrounded by time and immune from it. It’s a place of hearing family stories and passing them on. A place of remembering parents, grandparents and relatives through photographs and portraits on the walls but also by sitting where they sat, doing what they did, and teaching what they taught. It’s a place so thick with memory that a man there is every age he’s ever been — a tyke clutching his mother’s hand, a boy skippering his first boat alone, a teen reveling by a midnight fire, a grown man helping his father walk familiar paths, and a father placing his son’s hand on the tiller. Amidst it all, the rocks and islands never change, and the cottage is always there upon return.

Changing such a place has its perils. It doesn’t matter if the tub leaks and hasn’t been used for a decade — “It’s always been there.” Or refinishing the beautiful maple floors long since stained over in a decision long forgotten — “That’s the character of the place.” And so it goes until it gets bad enough that those who weren’t born into it band together and foment rebellion — “I’m not going there any more unless we get a decent shower!”

This kind of insurrection happens even in the best of families, and it’s during these periods that change visits the cottage. (It’s always the women!) And so this year, the family took the rare step of not only agreeing to fix up the cottage but also consenting to spend money on it. The idea this summer is to redo two bathrooms and transform a dark and creepy upstairs hallway into a bright reading and desk area by adding two new windows overlooking a beautiful marsh.

It’s easy to see why change is both necessary and hard to come by on the island. We live in a world dominated by its vagaries, and, like a receding hairline, many of them are unwelcome. We cling to the idea of a place beyond the reach of change and time, even as we do what’s necessary to preserve it.

In the end, we bring the old cottage slowly along with us — amazed when we improve it, and wondering what took us so long. It’s not so very different from our lives elsewhere — the greater our connection, the more intense the feeling.

We enjoy our season in the sun and take our turn in the line of caretakers. We learn the same lessons as those who preceded us: balancing the need for the new with respect for the old; forging progress despite our differences; and doing what we can to protect and continue our family’s perch on an island in time.


Douglas Heuck

A journalistic innovator, Heuck has been writing about Pittsburgh for 25 years, as an investigative reporter and business editor at The Pittsburgh Press and Post-​Gazette and as the founder of Pittsburgh Quarterly. His newspaper projects ranged from living on the streets disguised as a homeless man to penning the only comprehensive profile in the latter years of polio pioneer Dr. Jonas Salk to creating a statistical means of judging regional progress that has led to similar projects across the country. Heuck’s work has won numerous national, state and local writing awards. His work has been cited in the landmark media law case “Food Lion vs. ABC news.”

Explore Related Stories:

Other stories in this category: « The Sword Over the City Fallow Ground »
Close Window Welcome to Pittsburgh Quarterly
Keep up with the latest

Sign up for our Newsletter, Pittsburgh Quarterly This Week.

We’ll keep in touch, but only when we think there’s something worth sharing. To receive exclusive Pittsburgh Quarterly news and stories, please fill out the form below. Be sure to check your email for a link to confirm your subscription!

View past newsletters here.

Don’t miss a story! Sign up for our newsletter to receive award-​winning journalism in your inbox.

Please let us know your name.
Invalid Input
Please let us know your email address.
Invalid Input